After more than 30 years of playing each other, Island and West Isle Little Leagues officially became one, merging into Galveston Little League for the 2023 season and beyond. The months-long merge process was authorized in March of 2022 after receiving an in-favor vote from both boards. Prior to that point, community input, feedback from parents and coaches, and discussions with District management played a key role.

West Isle and Island Little Leagues formed a special committee comprised of three board members from each league to negotiate the terms. Erik Carner, Chris Brownlee and Dave Spence represented West Isle, and Blanca Flores, Rosemary Trevino and Mike Dean represented Island. After months of meetings and decisions, the merge process was complete in November of 2022.

There had been two leagues in Galveston for more than three decades. Prior to that, the Island had up to four smaller Little League charters.